NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA - SAVOR THE TRADITION SINCE 1990!

Crafted with Passion, Baked to Perfection!

From the Heart of New York to Your Table: Only the Finest Cheeses, Richest Tomato Sauce, and Premium Flour - Our Love for Pizza, Reflected in Decades of Craft.

Order now

REVIEWS

OUR GUESTS SPEAK OUT

Discover why our patrons say All-Star Pizza is more than just a meal—it's a slice of New York with a Miami twist, right here in our community. Real stories from our pizza family, sharing how our handcrafted pies and heartfelt service have created memorable experiences and why they keep coming back for more.

Tainã Oliveira da Silva

The best New York-style pizza in Miami, hands down!! You simply must order the pepperoni cup with the hot honey! The service is excellent, and I am always greeted with a friendly face and a warm welcome.

M T

The pizza is always perfectly cooked with a delicious sauce and just the right amount of cheese and/or toppings. I enjoy getting the 2 slices with drink because it’s shareable and has a crispy crust. Yummy! The garlic rolls are cooked just right, not a heavy dough and not overpowering in garlic sauce (some places make it with too much oil). I’ve used delivery, dine-in, and takeout and always consistent in flavors and service. Thank you!

Ricardo Arguello

NGL this Pizza is fireeee! Fireee! Yall have to try it well done is the play. Whenever you are going to hang out with your girlfriend or wether its to just chill and game night with the boys, this pizza hits different!!! This pizza will definitely be catering at my wedding, thank you All Star Pizza for being a 5 star Pizza. 10/10 come get it!

Join Our Newsletter

Join our newsletter today, and get access to exclusive offers and coupon codes. You are only an email away.

To Top
Product added to cart